Keystone XL Pipeline: Construction Halt and Environmental Concerns

Explore the intricacies of the Keystone XL pipeline—its development, halt, and controversy surrounding environmental impacts and economic benefits.

{ “## The Keystone XL Pipeline Journey”,

“The Keystone XL pipeline was designed to transport oil from Alberta, Canada, to refineries in the United States. Developed by TC Energy (formerly TransCanada Corporation), this project was part of a series of pipelines constructed between Canada and the U.S. since 2010.”,

“In March 2019, then-President Donald Trump issued a Presidential permit for the pipeline’s construction that would traverse the United States-Canada border. However, on Jan. 20, 2021, President Joe Biden reversed this permit via an executive order.”,

“### Key Insights”,

##:

“* Proposed by TC Energy in 2005 to transport heavy oil from Canada’s oil sands to U.S. refineries.”

  • Keystone XL pipeline could cover a length of 2,687 miles (4,324 km).

  • It faced years of controversy over environmental impacts.

  • On Jan. 20, 2021, President Biden rescinded the pipeline’s construction permit.

“## Visualizing the Keystone XL Pipeline Plan”,

“Initially unveiled by TransCanada Corp. in 2005, the Keystone Pipeline was hailed as a strategic move to convert an existing natural gas pipeline to facilitate the transportation of crude oil. The following were components of its extensive layout:”,

“1. First Phase: Connected Hardisty, Alberta, with junctions at Steele City, Nebraska, then extended to refineries in Roxana, Illinois, and the Patoka Oil Terminal Hub.”,

“2. Second Phase: Ran from Steele City through Kansas to Cushing, Oklahoma, and down to Nederland, Texas, to support refineries in Port Arthur.”,

“3. Third Phase: The Houston Lateral pipeline aimed to ferry crude oil from Liberty County, Texas to refineries and terminals in the Houston area.”,

Political Tug-of-War:

In Nov. 2015, President Barack Obama announced his administration would not grant construction permits for the pipeline to bolster climate change efforts. In contrast, President Trump’s administration endorsed the pipeline, claiming it would generate jobs and boost economic growth. However, President Biden’s executive order in Jan. 2021 decisively halted the project, which TC Energy had already retracted earlier that day.",

Mechanism of the Keystone Pipeline:

The Keystone system was envisioned to carry diluted bitumen and synthetic crude oil across multiple U.S. states. Extracted from Canada’s oil sands, this heavy oil, which has unique refining requirements, uses a process known for emitting substantial particulate matter and chemicals like sulfides and hydrogen cyanide. The complete Keystone XL pipeline was projected to transport over 800,000 barrels of oil daily.",

“### Environmental Conversations Continued”,

Environmental activists, policymakers and local residents persistently opposed the Keystone pipeline aggressively. Citing the proximity to Nebraska’s Sandhill region and the Ogallala aquifer—an essential water source for U.S. crops, these groups highlighted high greenhouse gas emissions resulting from oil sands bitumen transportation.",

-Grastal, National Resource Defense Council (NRDC), pursuing legal actions multiple times including in 2017, 2019, and in July 2020 to impede the pipeline constructions. According to the NRDC tar sands oil prone to corrosion posing leak and spill threats. As illustration in October 2019, North Dakota suffered 378,000 gallons tar sands crude spill.",

Advocates vs. Critics",

Related Terms: TransCanada Corp, oil refineries, crude oil, bitumen, environmental impact.

References

  1. TransCanada. “TransCanada Proposes Keystone Oil Pipeline Project”.
  2. U.S. Government Publishing Office. “Presidential Permit—Authorizing TransCanada Keystone Pipeline, L.P., To Construct, Connect, Operate, and Maintain Pipeline Facilities at the International Boundary Between the United States and Canada”, Pages 1-3.
  3. The White House. “Executive Order on Protecting Public Health and the Environment and Restoring Science to Tackle the Climate Crisis”.
  4. TC Energy. “Overview”.
  5. TC Energy. “Keystone Pipeline System”.
  6. The White House. “Statement by the President on the Keystone XL Pipeline”.
  7. U.S. Government Publishing Office. “Memorandum on Construction of the Keystone XL Pipeline”, Pages 1-3.
  8. Keystone XL. “About Keystone XL”.
  9. United States Department of Agriculture. “Ogallala Aquifer Initiative”.
  10. Natural Resources Defense Council. “What Is the Keystone XL Pipeline?”
  11. Natural Resources Defense Council. “The Keystone XL Pipeline”.

Get ready to put your knowledge to the test with this intriguing quiz!

--- primaryColor: 'rgb(121, 82, 179)' secondaryColor: '#DDDDDD' textColor: black shuffle_questions: true --- ## What is the Keystone XL Pipeline primarily designed for? - [ ] To transport water across states - [x] To transport crude oil from Canada to the United States - [ ] To connect major cities by railway - [ ] To deliver natural gas to rural areas ## Which sectors are majorly impacted by the Keystone XL Pipeline? - [ ] Agriculture and education - [ ] Financial services and tourism - [x] Energy and transportation - [ ] Healthcare and tech ## What is a key environmental concern associated with the Keystone XL Pipeline? - [ ] Increased traffic congestion - [ ] Water scarcity - [ ] Air quality improvement - [x] Risk of oil spills and pollution ## Which countries are primarily connected by the Keystone XL Pipeline proposal? - [x] Canada and the United States - [ ] United States and Mexico - [ ] Canada and Mexico - [ ] United States and Brazil ## What is a major economic argument for the development of the Keystone XL Pipeline? - [ ] It will reduce costs for housing development - [x] It will create jobs and promote energy independence - [ ] It will improve school infrastructures - [ ] It will decrease the demand for electric vehicles ## The Keystone XL Pipeline is often associated with which type of crude oil? - [ ] Sweet crude - [ ] Low-sulfur crude - [ ] Synthetic crude - [x] Tar sands oil ## What was a significant regulatory review process that the Keystone XL Pipeline had to undergo? - [ ] U.S. Department of Education assessment - [x] Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) - [ ] Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) safety review - [ ] U.S. Department of Agriculture approval ## Opposition to the Keystone XL Pipeline typically focuses on which concerns? - [ ] Increasing cost of education - [x] Environmental protection and indigenous rights - [ ] Technological obsolescence - [ ] Passenger transportation inefficiencies ## Which U.S. president revoked the permit for the Keystone XL Pipeline in 2021? - [ ] Donald Trump - [ ] George W. Bush - [ ] Barack Obama - [x] Joe Biden ## What is one reason proponents advocate for the continuation of the Keystone XL Pipeline? - [ ] To expand public transportation networks - [x] To enhance energy security - [ ] To reduce high-speed internet costs - [ ] To implement water conservation measures