Unlocking the Secrets of Gresham’s Law: How Bad Money Drives Out Good
Gresham’s Law is a principle that highlights how “bad money drives out good” and can be applied to currency markets. The concept originated from the historical use of precious metals in coinage and their respective value. Even with the abandonment of metallic currency standards, the theory remains pertinent in discussing the stability and movement of different currencies in modern global markets.
Key Insights
- Historical Influence: Sir Thomas Gresham, a financier born in 1519, wrote extensively about the minting and value of coins. He observed that legally overvalued currency tends to drive undervalued currency out of circulation.
- Currency Debasement: The principle also notes the effects of currency debasement—where the reduction in precious metal content in coins decreased their market value.
Understanding the Impact
Sir Thomas Gresham, who founded the Royal Exchange of the City of London, detailed the effects of currency debasement on coin circulation during his lifetime. For example, when Henry VIII debased the English shilling by reducing its silver content, citizens began hoarding higher silver content coins. People would spend lesser-valued coins (bad money) and keep coins with more intrinsic value (good money) out of circulation.
Historical and Modern Examples
-
Good Money vs. Bad Money: Traditionally, coins were made from gold, silver, and other precious metals, providing intrinsic value. Debased coins, containing less metal, were often legally overvalued. When legally obligated to treat both coin types equally, people quickly offloaded their less-valued coins and hoarded the more valuable ones.
-
Modern Economy with Legal Tender Laws: Today’s legal tender laws mandate all currency units to be recognized at the same face value. This requirement forces Gresham’s Law into play, leading to inflation in most economies as issuers can print money into existence. History offers a dramatic example—during Zimbabwe’s hyperinflation in 2008, the Zimbabwe dollar became nearly worthless, leading to the economy’s eventual dollarization. Stable foreign currencies surged in use, effectively driving the hyperinflated local currency out of day-to-day transactions.
A Real-World Example
In 1982, the U.S. altered the composition of the penny to consist of 97.5% zinc. Pre-1982 copper pennies became more valuable. As copper prices soared, attempts to mitigate the exploitation of metal value led to strict penalties for melting pennies. This case mirrors Gresham’s Law, with legally mandated value overruling intrinsic metal content.
Legal Tender Laws and Gresham’s Law’s Modern Relevance
Countries implement legal tender laws to enforce a standard currency for all debts and financial obligations. The advent of paper money provides a rich modern context for Gresham’s Law. Legal tender ensures a uniform face value for currency, compelling people to offload decreasingly valuable tender for more valuable tender, repeating historical patterns. During times of severe inflation, such as the paper money debacles in the Revolutionary War U.S., the pattern is stark and impacts both personal habits and governmental policies universally.
The Bottom Line
Gresham’s Law illustrates an enduring monetary principle: “bad money drives out good.” Initially tied to precious metals in coinage, its lessons echo into today’s fiat economies despite the global shift away from metal-backed standards. Understanding Gresham’s Law provides crucial insights into currency market behaviors, the dynamics of inflation, and legislative effects on economies worldwide.
Related Terms: bad money, good money, debasement, legal tender, inflation
References
- National Science Foundation. “Multimedia Gallery”.
- Macrotrends. “Copper Prices 45 Year Historical Chart”.
- Code of Federal Regulations. “Part 82 - 5 Cent and One Cent Coin Regulations”.
- Advisors Capital Management. “Gresham’s Law”.
