Understanding Flotation Costs: A Key to Navigating New Equity Issuances

Learn about flotation costs, an essential consideration for publicly-traded companies issuing new securities. Understand how these expenses can impact capital raising and how to calculate them efficiently.

Unveiling the Mystery behind Flotation Costs

Flotation costs are expenses incurred by a publicly-traded company when it issues new securities, including underwriting fees, legal fees, and registration fees. These costs affect the amount of capital that can be raised from the new issue. Companies must factor in flotation costs, expected return on equity, dividend payments, and the percentage of retained earnings to determine the cost of new equity.

Key Takeaways

  • Flotation costs are incurred when a company issues new stock.
  • These costs include underwriting, legal, registration, and audit fees.
  • Expressed as a percentage of the issue price, flotation costs reduce the capital raised.
  • Companies use a weighted average cost of capital (WACC) to decide funding shares from new equity and debt.
  • Analysts argue that flotation costs should be adjusted out of future cash flows to avoid overstating the cost of capital.

What Do Flotation Costs Tell You?

Companies have two principal ways to raise capital: through debt instruments such as bonds and loans, or through equity. Some prefer debt, particularly when interest rates are low since the interest on loans can often be tax-deductible, whereas equity returns are not.

Equity does not require repayment, which is its biggest advantage. However, it involves giving up ownership stakes and can be a costly venture due to associated flotation costs, such as investment banking fees, legal charges, and fees for listing on a stock exchange.

The flotation cost of new equity, usually lower in price than existing equity, is incorporated into the share value, ultimately reducing the total capital raised.

Flotation Cost Formula

To calculate the flotation cost of new equity using the dividend growth rate formula:

$$ (Dividend \ Growth \ Rate \ = \ \frac{D_1}{P \left(1 - F\right)} + g) $$
Where:

  • D1 = Dividend in the next period
  • P = Issue price per share
  • F = Ratio of flotation cost to stock issue price
  • g = Dividend growth rate

Example of a Flotation Cost Calculation

Assume Company A needs to raise $100 million by issuing common stock at $10 per share. Investment bankers receive 7% of the capital raised. The expected dividend next year is $1 per share, anticipated to grow by 10% the following year.

Using these values, the cost of new equity is calculated as follows:

$$ (Cost \ of \ New \ Equity = \ \frac{1}{10 \left(1 - 0.07\right)} + 0.10 = 20.7%) $$
Without flotation cost:
$$ (\frac{1}{10 \left(1 - 0\right)} + 0.10 = 20.0%) $$
The difference, which is 0.7%, represents the increase in the cost of new equity due to flotation costs.

Limitations of Using Flotation Costs

Some debate that including flotation costs in the company’s cost of equity implies perpetual expenses, overstating the cost of capital. To manage this, some analysts adjust the company’s cash flows for flotation costs.

What Does Flotation Mean?

In financial terms, flotation means publicly selling company shares for the first time. This is a widespread method for companies to generate funds for expansion.

What Is the Flotation Price?

The flotation price is the initial price that the public can purchase shares for, also inclusive of the costs the company incurs issuing these securities.

What Is the Main Flotation Cost?

Underwriting fees, charged by investment banks during initial public offerings (IPOs), typically constitute the largest flotation cost. These fees range between 4%-7% of gross proceeds and cover preparation, marketing, pricing, and the risks undertaken by the underwriters.

The Bottom Line

  • Raising capital through new securities includes considerable costs via underwriting, legal, and other transactional fees, known as flotation costs.
  • Expressed as a percentage of the issue price, these costs vary by security type, issue size, and transaction risks. Companies should estimate these costs beforehand to ensure this method is cost-effective for raising funds.

Related Terms: Underwriting Fees, Return on Equity, Weighted Average Cost of Capital.

References

  1. PricewaterhouseCoopers. “Considering an IPO? First, Understand the Costs”.

Get ready to put your knowledge to the test with this intriguing quiz!

--- primaryColor: 'rgb(121, 82, 179)' secondaryColor: '#DDDDDD' textColor: black shuffle_questions: true --- ## What are flotation costs? - [ ] The costs associated with buying and selling securities in the stock market. - [ ] The costs companies incur when hiring new employees. - [x] The costs incurred by a company when issuing new securities. - [ ] The costs related to maintaining inventory. ## Why might a company consider flotation costs when deciding to raise funds? - [ ] To assess long-term warranty obligations. - [x] To determine the actual cost of raising new capital. - [ ] To estimate employee training expenses. - [ ] To calculate dividend payout ratios. ## Which of the following expenses can be classified under flotation costs? - [x] Underwriting fees. - [ ] Employee salaries. - [ ] Maintenance expenses. - [ ] Office rent. ## How do flotation costs affect a company's capital structure? - [ ] They increase cash flow from operations. - [ ] They decrease the need for debt financing. - [x] They increase the overall cost of new equity. - [ ] They eliminate the need for retained earnings. ## In which scenario are flotation costs typically higher? - [ ] Issuing short-term bonds. - [ ] Obtaining a bank loan. - [ ] Leasing equipment. - [x] Issuing new equity. ## Which type of securities generally involves higher flotation costs? - [ ] Treasury bonds. - [x] Common stock. - [ ] Term deposits. - [ ] Municipal bonds. ## How are flotation costs treated in financial modeling? - [ ] They are ignored as non-cash expenses. - [x] They are added to the cost of new financing method. - [ ] They are subtracted from operating expenses. - [ ] They are included in SG&A expenses. ## Which of the following is a way for a company to manage flotation costs? - [ ] Increasing annual dividends. - [ ] Hiring more sales personnel. - [ ] Minimizing inventory. - [x] Negotiating lower underwriting fees. ## How might high flotation costs affect a company’s decision to issue new equity? - [ ] They will encourage more frequent issuance of new equity. - [ ] They will not impact the decision-making process. - [ ] They will prioritize issuing short-term debt. - [x] They may discourage the issuance of new equity due to increased costs. ## Which parties are typically involved in flotation costs? - [ ] Human resource departments. - [ ] Inventory managers. - [x] Investment bankers and underwriters. - [ ] IT support staff.