Mastering the Butterfly Spread: A Guide to Options Trading

Unlock the secrets of the butterfly spread, a market-neutral trading strategy combining bull and bear spreads with limited risk and capped profits. Learn to leverage this options strategy to maximize returns in steady markets.

What Is a Butterfly Spread?

The butterfly spread is an options strategy that balances bull and bear spreads, offering fixed risk and capped profit potential. Designed as a market-neutral method, this strategy shines when the underlying asset remains stable until the option expires. It involves four options—calls, puts, or a mix—across three strike prices.

Key Takeaways

  • Combines bull and bear spreads for a balanced options strategy.
  • Market-neutral, with fixed risk and capped returns.
  • Thrives when the underlying asset remains stable until expiration.
  • Uses four options at three distinct strike prices.
  • Strike prices equally spaced from the center, at-the-money point.

Understanding Butterfly Spreads

Butterfly spreads cater to options traders seeking stability. An option is a financial instrument tied to an underlying asset like a stock or commodity, enabling buyers to execute transactions by a specified expiration date.

Combining both bull and bear spreads, a butterfly spread leverages four options contracts with a shared expiration and three varied strike prices:

  • Higher strike price
  • At-the-money strike price
  • Lower strike price

The higher and lower strike prices maintain equal distances from the at-the-money strike. For instance, if at-the-money is $60, the other strikes should be symmetrically higher and lower—$55 and $65. Both calls and puts can configure a butterfly spread, shifting it towards profit from either volatility or stability.

Types of Butterfly Spreads

Long Call Butterfly Spread

Involves buying one in-the-money call, writing two at-the-money calls, and buying one out-of-the-money call. Enters the trade with a net debit. Profit peaks if the underlying price matches the written calls at expiration, with maximum losses limited to the initial premiums.

Short Call Butterfly Spread

Formed by selling one in-the-money call, buying two at-the-money calls, and selling one out-of-the-money call. Generates a net credit. Maximizes profit if the underlying trades above the upper strike or below the lower strike at expiration, with loss constrained by the premium received.

Long Put Butterfly Spread

Involves buying one put at a lower strike, selling two at-the-money puts, and buying a higher strike put. Enters the position with net debt and seeks maximum profit when the underlying remains at the middle strike price by expiration.

Short Put Butterfly Spread

Created by selling one out-of-the-money put, buying two at-the-money puts, and selling an in-the-money put. Realizes profit if the underlying lies outside the strike bounds at expiration. The risk remains within the premiums received.

Iron Butterfly Spread

Integrates one out-of-the-money put, one at-the-money put, one at-the-money call, and one out-of-the-money call. Ideal for low volatility, the strategy brings net credit. Maximum profits occur at the middle strike price, with losses confined by premium subtractions.

Reverse Iron Butterfly Spread

Combines selling an out-of-the-money put, buying an at-the-money put, buying an at-the-money call, and selling an out-of-the-money call. Suitable for high volatility, this net debit strategy profits when the price surpasses the strike bounds.

Example of a Long Call Butterfly Spread

Consider Verizon (VZ) trades at $60. Expecting minimal movement, an investor executes a long call butterfly spread for potential gains. By writing two $60 strike call options and buying a $55 call and a $65 call, the maximum profit occurs if Verizon stays at $60 until expiration. The loss peaks if the price significantly deviates from $55 or $65.

Assuming an initial cost of $2.50, profit occurs when Verizon prices between $57.50 and $62.50 at expiration, excluding commission costs.

Characteristics of a Butterfly Spread

Comprising four options contracts with the same expiration but three distinct strike prices, the butterfly spread ranges through higher, at-the-money, and lower strikes. Maximum profit and loss are confined. For alternative strategies, the Christmas tree involves six options contracts.

Constructing a Long Call Butterfly Spread

Buy one in-the-money call, sell (write) two at-the-money calls, and buy one out-of-the-money call, creating net debt. Maximum profit is reached if the asset price at expiration meets the strike of the written calls, whereas losses are limited to the initial premium payments.

Constructing a Long Put Butterfly Spread

Buy one out-of-the-money put, sell (write) two at-the-money puts, and buy one in-the-money put, also creating net debt. Profits peak if the underlying asset resides at the central strike price. Maximum losses align with initial premiums and commissions.

Related Terms: option strategy, bull spread, bear spread, iron butterfly spread, reverse iron butterfly spread.

References

  1. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. “Options”.

Get ready to put your knowledge to the test with this intriguing quiz!

--- primaryColor: 'rgb(121, 82, 179)' secondaryColor: '#DDDDDD' textColor: black shuffle_questions: true --- ## What is a Butterfly Spread strategy in options trading? - [ ] Buying both call and put options of the same strike price - [x] Combining bull and bear spreads with three different strike prices - [ ] Selling short-term options and buying long-term options - [ ] Executing a calendar spread ## How many strike prices are involved in a Butterfly Spread? - [ ] One - [ ] Two - [x] Three - [ ] Four ## What are the main components of a Butterfly Spread? - [ ] Two options with the same strike price - [x] Two options with lower and higher strike prices, and double the position at a middle strike price - [ ] One option that is bought and one that is sold - [ ] Three put options with descending strike prices ## Which market outlook is best suited for a Butterfly Spread? - [ ] Bullish - [ ] Bearish - [x] Neutral - [ ] Extremely volatile ## In a long Butterfly Spread, what is typically done with the central strike price? - [x] Sell twice the amount of options compared to the outer strikes - [ ] Buy twice the amount of options compared to the outer strikes - [ ] Ignore the central strike price altogether - [ ] Use it as a placeholder ## How does the max profit in a Butterfly Spread occur? - [ ] When the underlying asset experiences significant movement - [ ] If options are held until expiration regardless of pricing - [x] When the underlying asset price is at the central strike price at expiration - [ ] When the options have the highest implied volatility ## What is the maximum loss in a Butterfly Spread? - [ ] Unlimited - [ ] Equal to the premium paid twice the strike width - [x] Limited to the net debit paid - [ ] Equivalent to owning the underlying asset directly ## When is a Short Butterfly Spread with Calls typically implemented? - [ ] When low volatility is expected - [ ] When a moderate downward trend is expected - [ ] When the market is highly unpredictable - [x] When significant short repositioning is expected around the outer strikes ## In which scenarios would a trader avoid using a Butterfly Spread? - [ ] Highly neutral market outlook - [x] Extremely high volatility expectation - [ ] Moderate bullish expectations - [ ] No premiums involved ## What's the purpose of establishing both upper and lower strikes in a Butterfly Spread? - [ ] To confuse other market participants - [x] To cap potential losses and gains, creating a defined risk tolerant structure - [ ] To match the hedge fund strategies - [ ] To synchronize with other non-traditional options strategies